billpalmer.net is sponsored by...
LoadPod: let us rip your CD collection into your iPod so that you don't have to.
Advertise on billpalmer.net: Macintosh advertising for the rest of us
billpalmer.net Macintosh users, you've never had it so good.

Macintosh Home Consulting Educators Database of Macintosh-Using Businesses About Contact Blog Interviews Discussion Boards Online Mac User Group Internships Store Merchandise Support Advertising Archives

Bill Palmer Consulting: Macintosh support for the rest of us. Serving Orlando and Central Florida


Eazy Draw new version 1.6.2

Visit the rest of the billpalmer.network:

Mac Using Educators .com

Mac Mischief: get your daily dose of Macintosh news

iPod Garage: the digital music site for the rest of us


the online Mac User Group

officially recognized by Apple as an
"Apple User Group"

Current membership:
497

Online iChat meetings the first Monday of every month

Newsletter with reviews, discounts and special offers

Access to the Apple MUG Store

Join today!


Ultimate cool gifts for 2004:


Belkin iPod
battery backup

Shop Amazon
and support billpalmer.net!


Advertise on billpalmer.net
Get your Missing Manuals:

MacOS X Panther
iPod and iTunes
Switching to Mac
AppleWorks 6
MS Office X
Dreamweaver MX






Bill buys a new Mac, volume one: I haven't done this in awhile

Monday, April 12th, 2004  by Bill Palmer

Well, I hope everyone had a good weekend, and thanks goes to all the readers who pointed me toward the blatant piece of pure fiction that Mr. Manzione over at Macnet v2 managed to hurl in my direction. Rest assured, I'll take care of him later. But while that puts him at the top of the stench meter, debunking his nonsense is not atop my list of priorities. I've got other fish to fry (including some salmon), but the biggest Mac-related fish involves doing something that I have yet to do this century: I've got to buy a new Mac.

Yeah, that's right, you read correctly. Shocking as it sounds, I haven't bought myself a computer since 1999. Actually, it was September of that year when I purchased a first-generation blueberry iBook to complement the first-gen bondi blue iMac I'd bought myself the previous year. Both machines served me remarkably well. But a year and a half after buying the iBook, I was issued a much more powerful Indigo iBook from my employer, which began to more and more frequently become my home machine of choice on the evenings and weekends. Soon I realized that I didn't need to own a Mac of my own at all, so I passed the (by then) aging bondi iMac along to a family member and kept ye olde iBook around merely as a backup.

Although I could have had the public elementary school I was working for offer me just about any extravagant laptop I wanted, I kept it modest, sticking with an Indigo iBook up until my final year in which I finally accepted a snow white G3 iBook in its place (an ergonomically inferior design, for sure, but the giant speed boost made up for it, barely). But when I finally retired from the job last fall, I realized that suddenly, I no longer had access to a computer that was less than four years old. Not good. And while my years-old blueberry iBook ran Panther surprisingly well and performed light duties quite admirably, it wasn't the answer as far as what I wanted to do with my growing family of websites. I needed to find something, and fast.

So I made arrangements to put a 500 Mhz slot-loading iMac in front of me (even though technically, it's not mine), and considering that it's now three years old itself, it's come a lot closer to meeting my needs than I thought it would. In fact, it's a testament to just how many years Macs can stay relevant, even with nothing more than the usual RAM and OS upgrades. But for reasons that are likely of no interest to anyone but me, I've now got about a six week window in which to put a new Mac in front of me. And while I've given quite a bit of advice on the subject to a whole lot of people who've asked for it over the years (and a few who haven't), it's been awhile since I've had to advise myself on the subject. No problem, as it's a truly wonderful time to be buying a new Mac. But clearly I've got some decisions to make.

So I'm going to turn the tables here. Over the next week or two, I'm going to air out my thoughts on various models and features, in the hopes that I can figure out just what it is that I really want and need. And I'll be looking for input from readers as I go along. Now I'll warn you that this isn't an episode of American Idol; I'm not going to simply ask for advice and then buy whatever gets the most votes (besides, some of those rabid G4 Cube users are likely to vote more than once). Everyone's situation is different, and the hardest part for me just might lie in figuring out just what my situation is.

I know that I need a Mac, but the certainties pretty much end there. Knowing what I want is easy enough: a dual 2 Ghz PowerMac G5 with a 23 inch Cinema Display, with a G5 PowerBook laptop thrown in to boot. The problem, of course, is that the first machine costs about five grand, and the second doesn't even exist yet. As with so many choices in life, this isn't about what I want; it's about what I need. Or more accurately, balancing various needs against each other and seeing which priorities make the cut vs. which ones I find I can live without after all.

There's also a matter of unique timing here. While it usually happens only once or perhaps twice a year, I have little doubt that we'll see new eMacs if not iMacs before my six week window expires. No, I don't have any inside information, I don't know anything that you don't. I'm just working under the assumption that Apple can't literally go forever without updating its consumer line, and recent signs would appear to be pointing that we'll see the new stuff sooner than later. So does this complicate things? Sure. But it's a good complication, because assuming I can hold out until we see the new models, I'll have the choice of getting a new machine at current prices, or scavenging for an outgoing machine at a discount. It's a good problem to have.

I welcome the challenge in front of me, and despite the number of unknowns, and the sort of do-or-die nature of the situation, I can't help but think that I'll come out on top no matter what. Every consumer Mac is a good deal; I've just got the find the one that best suits my needs. I've long said that the eMac more than meets the needs of ninety percent of consumers, and I really do believe that, but I do want to take a look at what the landscape might look like if I were to betray my own advice. Hey, it can't hurt, as everything is still hypothetical for at least a bit longer on my part. All the upside would appear to lie with waiting until the last possible moment, or until the situation with the new models becomes clear, whichever comes first. So in the mean time, I'll be taking a look at this from as many angles as I can, and hopefully we'll all figure out a bit more about what we really need out of our next Mac in the process.

Look for "Bill buys a new Mac, volume two" soon. Oh, and Mr. Manzione, I'd advise you to write keep writing your fiction as quickly as you can, buddy, 'cause I'll be dealing with you soon enough.

No Panther user should be without:

You'll never guess what's happening in the iPod Garage.

Get your daily dose of Apple news from Mac Mischief.

Click here to read Bill's Blog.

Give Bill a shout, or share your thoughts over on the billpalmer.net discussion boards. And if you haven't joined the online MUG yet, then you're not among the 419 coolest Mac users on earth.


Hey...wanna help billpalmer.net pay for all this fancy new bandwidth?


Other content on billpalmer.net:

Don't mess with Mac users, the bad karma will kill you
Wednesday, March 31st  by Bill Palmer

BuyMusic.comedown: first iTunes competitor becomes first to give up
Tuesday, March 30th  by Bill Palmer

Just how spoiled have we Mac users become?
Monday, March 29th  by Bill Palmer

At least now we know that Dell is afraid of the G5
Friday, March 26th  by Bill Palmer

Why the next decade of Macintosh will be golden
Wednesday, March 24th  by Bill Palmer

Bill's Blog: Something else entirely
Tuesday, March 23rd  by Bill Palmer

The Rotten Core of Apple
Monday, March 22nd  by Will Robertson

Steve's original mission at Apple is complete. Now here comes the fun part.
Friday, March 19th  by Bill Palmer

Here's what I think: Microsoft's outrageous claims, and what Apple's employees are really doing with their spare time
Thursday, March 18th  by Bill Palmer

I think Macs are my favorite computer!!!
Tuesday, March 16th by Steve Johnson

Despite reports, Apple is well on its way to reaching 100 million song goal
Tuesday, March 16th  by Bill Palmer

Use IMAP for a Better Email Experience, Part II
Monday, March 15th by Seth Dimbert

Apple's grand scheme to create an army of "Mac users in training" enters Phase Two
Monday, March 15th by Bill Palmer

Feedback and distortion: paying Bill Gates for email, cheap PC's, and other things I can't stand
Sunday, March 14th by Bill Palmer

When do we get to throw away our printers?
Saturday, March 13th by Bill Palmer

Will Mac OS X come under attack from SCO/Microsoft?
Friday, March 12th by Steve Johnson

Use IMAP for a Better Email Experience, Part I
Thursday, March 11th by Seth Dimbert

Blog: ...and your podium is gone
Thursday, March 11th by Bill Palmer

Macintosh users, you've never had it so good
Thursday, March 11th by Bill Palmer

Rumors of our demise...rumors of our popularity...
Tuesday, March 9th by Bill Palmer

Praises and Criticisms for iPhoto '04
Monday, March 8th by Will Robertson

Die, headless iMac, die!
Monday, March 8th by Bill Palmer

Bill's Blog: back again, and almost entirely content-free
Sunday, March 7th by Bill Palmer

Dear Bill Gates: take your email proposal and shove it
Sunday, March 7th by Bill Palmer

Should Apple pretend to be selling a sub-$500 computer?
Friday, March 5th by Bill Palmer

How much worse is this sick headless iMac fantasy going to get?
Friday, March 5th by Bill Palmer

The identity of a Mac
Tuesday, March 2nd by Mark Duling

My Life and iLife, part 4: Keynote and other gimmicks
Tuesday, March 2nd by Bill Palmer

Online MUG meeting today!
Monday, March 1st site news

My Life and iLife: a day-by-day look inside my most important iLife project ever, Part 3
Friday, February 27th by Bill Palmer

My Life and iLife: a day-by-day look inside my most important iLife project ever, Part 2
Tuesday, February 24th by Bill Palmer

My Life and iLife: a day-by-day look inside my most important iLife project ever, Part 1
Monday, February 23rd by Bill Palmer

 

 


Don't have an iPod yet? Order one today:

iPod 40 GB
green iPod mini
pink iPod mini
blue iPod mini
silver iPod mini
gold iPod mini
The terms Apple, Mac, Macintosh, MacOS X, iMac, iBook, PowerBook, Power Macintosh, Safari, Keynote, Sherlock, iMovie, iPhoto, iTunes, iTunes Music Store, FileMaker Pro, AppleWorks, the Apple Store, and Apple Education are trademarks of Apple Computer, Inc. Other terms may be trademarks of their respective companies.

LoadPod: let us rip your CD collection into your iPod so that you don't have to.